Our Blog
PA Court Upholds DUI Conviction After “Welfare Check” on Highway RampPosted in DUI on August 10, 2025
The Pennsylvania Superior Court’s June 28, 2024 decision in Commonwealth v. Joshua W. Ward (2024 PA Super 133) highlights how a DUI arrest in Pennsylvania can result from a routine welfare check under the community caretaking doctrine. The case reaffirms that officers can approach and detain a driver without a warrant if they have objective… view more
Refusing A Blood Draw After Issuance of Warrant Can Lead to Obstruction ChargesPosted in DUI on August 10, 2025
In Commonwealth v. Palchanes (2019 PA Super 351), the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed a conviction for obstructing the administration of law after a driver refused to comply with a valid search warrant for a blood draw. This case is a clear warning that refusing a blood test after police obtain a warrant can lead to… view more
Centre County Judge Upholds Traffic Stop in Marijuana CasePosted in Fourth Amendment on August 10, 2025
The Court of Common Pleas of Centre County recently ruled in Commonwealth v. Klanish, CP-14-CR-922-2019, that evidence from a marijuana possession case would not be suppressed. This decision provides important guidance on Pennsylvania traffic stop laws, the authority of sheriff’s deputies, and when Miranda rights apply. Facts of the Case On April 30, 2019, a Centre… view more
Does a NY DWAI Count as a Prior Offense of DUI in PA?Posted in DUI on July 25, 2025
Case Background: Commonwealth v. Pombo Yes. In Commonwealth v. Pombo, the defendant was convicted in Pike County of DUI (controlled substance) and driving while his license was suspended due to a prior DUI. At sentencing, the Commonwealth sought to apply Pennsylvania’s mandatory minimum penalties for a third offense DUI, citing Pombo’s two prior New York… view more
PA Father Jailed After Secretly Recording Custody ConferencePosted in General on July 23, 2025
Many people watch TV and see people secretly recording meetings or discussions and assume that doing so is legal. In Pennsylvania, that is not the law, and ignorance of the law is no defense. In Commonwealth v. Cline, 2017 PA Super 417, the Cline had been convicted of violating the Wiretap and Electronic Surveillance Control… view more
PA Court Rules ARD IS a “Prior Offense” of DUI for License SuspensionPosted in ARD,DUI,License Suspension on July 23, 2025
If you’ve resolved a DUI in Pennsylvania through the ARD (Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition) program, you might think it won’t come back to haunt you, especially in light of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s recent decision in Commonwealth v. Shifflet. In that case, the Court ruled that ARD was NOT a prior offense of DUI for criminal sentencing… view more
PA Judge Upholds DUI Traffic Stop Based on Driving Too SlowlyPosted in Centre County DUI on July 21, 2025
In Commonwealth v. Surovec, CR-868-2024, the Centre County Court of Common Pleas denied a motion to suppress evidence after a DUI arrest, ruling that the traffic stop was lawful because the driver was traveling at an unreasonably slow speed. This case highlights how driving too slowly—if it disrupts traffic—can provide Pennsylvania law enforcement with probable… view more
PA Court Reverses Suppression of Drug EvidencePosted in Fourth Amendment on July 20, 2025
In Commonwealth v. Bentley, 1253 MDA 2024, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed the Lycoming County trial court’s decision to suppress evidence in a drug trafficking case. The ruling strengthens law enforcement’s ability to obtain search warrants based on tips from confidential informants and reinforces how courts should apply the “probable cause” standard. Controlled Buy Leads… view more
PA Court Upholds Conviction for Drug Delivery Death CasePosted in Constitutional Rights on July 20, 2025
In Commonwealth v. Bloom, 2025 PA Super 143, the Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the conviction of Bloom for drug delivery resulting in death (DDRD), delivery of a controlled substance, and recklessly endangering another person. addressed a constitutional challenge under the Confrontation Clause—a recurring issue in drug delivery resulting in death (DDRD) cases involving toxicology reports… view more
PA Court Reverses Marijuana Convictions Over Unreliable Search WarrantPosted in Fourth Amendment on July 18, 2025
In a pivotal ruling for Pennsylvania criminal defense law, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania reversed the drug convictions of two York County men—Charles and Timothy Manuel—after finding that the search warrant used to enter their home lacked sufficient probable cause. This en banc decision underscores the importance of police corroboration when relying on tips from… view more