Fourth Amendment

Judge Suppresses Evidence in State College Marijuana Case

A Centre County judge ruled that a vehicle stop and subsequent search of a vehicle were unconstitutional, resulting in the suppression of nearly an ounce of marijuana and related paraphernalia. The case, Commonwealth v. Max Jean,  serves as a critical reminder of the legal protections against unreasonable searches and seizures, particularly when police rely on odor-based… view more

PA Court Rules Traffic Stop Was Illegal, Suppresses Gun Evidence

Police often look for any reason to conduct a traffic stop to conduct a further investigation and look for drugs or guns. Such stops are called “pretextual”. Such stops routinely occur on interstate 80 in Centre County. The police conduct stops for people that follow too closely, have tinted windows, or drive in the left… view more

Marijuana Odor is a Factor in Probable Cause Consideration in PA

Can Police Still Use the Smell of Marijuana to Justify a Search in Pennsylvania? As marijuana laws continue to evolve, many Pennsylvanians wonder whether police officers can still rely on the smell of marijuana to justify a search of a home, vehicle, or other property. A recent Pennsylvania Superior Court decision, Commonwealth v. Batista, confirms… view more

PA Court Overturns Marijuana Conviction After Illegal Search

The Pennsylvania Superior Court recently issued a decision that reinforces the rights of homeowners to be free from warrantless police searches. In Commonwealth v. Duke, the Court ruled that evidence obtained from an illegal search of a man’s garage must be suppressed, leading to the dismissal of his marijuana manufacturing conviction. This case highlights the… view more